Expert Knife Appraisal Tips Every Collector Should Know

Knife appraisal is the process of evaluating a knife to determine its market value, historical significance, and collectibility. This evaluation can be useful for many purposes — whether you're looking to sell a knife, insure it, include it in an estate inventory, or simply understand more about your collection.

A professional appraisal typically considers several key factors:

  • Maker/Brand: The craftsman or company behind the knife greatly influences its value. Knives made by famous makers or brands (e.g., Bob Loveless, Randall Made Knives) are often highly sought after.
  • Age and History: Antique knives or those tied to historical events or famous individuals usually carry higher value.
  • Condition: Mint-condition knives are worth more than those with visible damage, rust, sharpening marks, or repairs.
  • Materials Used: Premium materials like Damascus steel, exotic wood, ivory, or mother-of-pearl can enhance a knife’s value.
  • Rarity and Limited Editions: Knives produced in small numbers, or rare models, typically fetch higher prices.
  • Provenance: Documentation that traces the history of ownership, authenticity certificates, and original packaging can significantly increase a knife’s appraisal value.

In short, knife appraisal isn’t just about pricing an item — it’s about understanding its story, craftsmanship, and place in the market.

Tips for an Accurate Knife Appraisal

If you're planning to have a knife appraised or want to make a rough self-assessment, keep these points in mind:

  • Identify the Maker: The maker's mark can tell a lot about a knife’s value. Knives crafted by famous artisans like Bob Loveless or Sam Lurquin can significantly increase a knife’s worth.
  • Examine Materials and Craftsmanship: Look at the blade material, handle composition, and overall construction quality. Materials like Damascus steel or ivory handles are especially valuable.
  • Assess the Condition: Take a close look for any signs of wear, damage, or repairs. Mint-condition knives are the most valuable.
  • Understand Rarity and Historical Importance: Determine if the knife is part of a limited run, or if it has a history that adds to its collectibility.
  • Gather Documentation: Maintain receipts, certificates of authenticity, original packaging, and any photographs that help establish provenance.

Following these tips will not only make your knife appraisal more accurate but also more valuable when it's time to sell.

After the Knife Appraisal: How to Sell Your Knife on KnifeMarket

Once you complete your knife appraisal and understand the value of your piece, you may decide it's time to sell. KnifeMarket makes it simple, secure, and fast to find a buyer.

Getting Started:

  • Sign up to KnifeMarket with your email address.
  • Create your first listing by selecting the correct category.
  • Add detailed information about the knife and upload quality photos. Remember, quality images significantly boost your chances of selling.
  • Set your own Return Policy.
  • Choose the shipping country.
  • Publish your listing.

Listing Verification:

To maintain transparency and trust, KnifeMarket requires proof of ownership through listing verification. After submitting your listing, you'll receive a random code via email. Write the code on paper, place it next to the knife, take a photo, and send it back to KnifeMarket for verification.

Stripe Connect Onboarding:

Before your knife can be sold, complete the Stripe Connect onboarding. This includes ID verification and providing bank account information. Until this process is complete, the "Add to Cart" button on your listing will remain hidden.

Shipping Your Knife:

KnifeMarket only allows shipping via trackable, insured courier labels they provide. Sellers cannot use their own shipping services. Shipping costs are automatically calculated and added at checkout. After accepting an order, you will have 5 business days to ship using the provided label.

Accepting an Order:

When a Buyer purchases your knife, you'll be notified via email. You have 72 hours to accept the order. Once accepted, the Buyer's funds are held in escrow until delivery confirmation. Make sure to pack your knife securely to avoid injuries during transport.

KnifeMarket's Commission Fee:

Creating a listing is free. KnifeMarket currently charges a promotional commission fee of only 1% on each completed sale — a fraction compared to other marketplaces. This fee will eventually increase to 7%, so now is the perfect time to join.

Receiving Payment:

After the Buyer confirms delivery (or automatically after seven days), funds will be released from escrow and transferred to your specified bank account. Please allow 1–3 business days for funds to appear.

Why Choose KnifeMarket After Knife Appraisal?

KnifeMarket is the first dedicated online marketplace for knives and knife-related products. It offers a secure, transparent, and easy-to-use platform for both sellers and buyers. Whether you have a new, pre-owned, rare, or antique knife, KnifeMarket is the best place to connect with collectors and enthusiasts worldwide.

From knife appraisal to final sale, KnifeMarket simplifies the entire process, providing you with professional support every step of the way.

Ready to turn your appraisal into a successful sale? Join KnifeMarket today and discover the safest and easiest way to sell your knives!

Join KnifeMarket